She looks at him for a long second, before she realises he's right.

He's right, and that's why she swaps tactics. She hesitates, then takes a deep breath. "Okay."

And then- "Okay. So.... rolling with it, but... I guess then-"

She pauses. "What are you the most scared of? Supernatural things, I mean. Because I guess that is what's important." Not if things existed, because he may or may not know, but either way - there's a set of things that are important. What's going to eat you in the night. That kind of thing.